Janice Turner – One day, we’ll look back on era of puberty blockers with horror:

In 2017 I interviewed Bernadette Wren, then head of psychology at the Tavistock Gids clinic, and asked what effect puberty blocking drugs have on the adolescent brain. Looking highly uncomfortable, she replied that the evidence so far was only anecdotal but that the clinic would study its patients “well into their adult lives so that we can see”.

Even back then, before whistleblowers had exposed the rush to medically transition children, it was alarming to hear that heavy-duty GnRH agonists such as triptorelin — used to treat advanced prostate cancer and “chemically castrate” sex offenders — were being prescribed to arrest puberty in hundreds of children as young as 11.

Moreover, they were being used “off-label” before any clinical trials. And the long-term study Wren promised never materialised: Gids (the Gender Identity Development Service) routinely lost touch with patients, and the 44 it did follow reported little long-term mental health improvement.

This shocking chapter in medical history, where the ideological objectives of trans rights campaigners trumped the welfare of disturbed children, is coming to an end worldwide….

Yet the question remains: how was this ever allowed to happen? For years, puberty blockers were cheerily billed as a mere “pause button”. In 2014, Dr Polly Carmichael, the last head of Gids before the Cass review ordered its closure, went on CBBC in a show called I Am Leo, saying of blockers: “The good thing is, if you stop the injections, it’s like pressing ‘start’ and the body carries on developing as it would if you hadn’t started.”

The BBC permitted her to make this unevidenced claim to an impressionable audience of six to 12-year-olds. Imagine hearing this as a developing girl, freaked out by your new breasts and periods. No wonder Gids referrals subsequently rocketed….

This repellent experiment — in which girls who like trucks or little boys who dress as princesses, and who invariably grow up to be gay, are corralled inexorably down a road towards life-changing treatments — belongs in the book of medical disgraces. As do the cheerleaders who raised money for Mermaids and those who persecuted whistleblowers or damned journalists asking questions as transphobic.

In 50 years, chemically freezing the puberty of healthy children with troubled minds will be regarded with the same horrified fascination as lobotomies — which, never forget, won the Portuguese neurologist Antonio Egas Moniz the 1949 Nobel prize.

Posted in

5 responses to “In the book of medical disgraces”

  1. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    You’ve mentioned Andrea Long Chu before. Look at this nonsense, written in Butler speak:
    https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/trans-rights-biological-sex-gender-judith-butler.html

    Like

  2. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Yes, I’ve seen people referencing it, but haven’t actually read it. I made a start this time, but gave up. Life, as they say, is too short.

    Like

  3. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    A taste of what you’re missing:
    Widespread discomfort at the largely fantastical idea that trans girls will always dominate in their chosen sports reflects a basic patriarchal belief that the physical advantages of being male are perfectly acceptable so long as they are possessed by men. (In this sense, sex division in sport is meant to enshrine inequality, not to mitigate it.)

    Like

  4. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Oh god. It’s so absurd – but then you have to go to the effort of working out why it’s so absurd.

    Like

  5. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    The commentary that I’ve seen focuses on his belief that any person at any age should be free to transition – the extreme trans position, as it were.
    See here – https://www.spiked-online.com/2024/03/15/no-child-has-the-right-to-transition/

    Like

Leave a comment