From the Telegraph – University spied on student over pro-Israel views:

The secret file held by Brodie Mitchell’s own university makes for terrifying reading. Across almost 1,500 pages, it contains details of surveillance of the politics and law student by university authorities; monitoring and tracking of his movements and social media posts; and perhaps most chillingly of all, reveals a secret referral to counter-terrorism police.

It is, he says, Orwellian. On one occasion, senior figures in the university reprimanded him for his attendance at a Remembrance Sunday service in the chapel; on another they expressed concern he had travelled to Golders Green, where he had stood in support of the Jewish community that had come under a terrorist attack.

Mr Mitchell, 20, who is softly spoken and measured, sits inside the grand dining hall of Royal Holloway, University of London, on its leafy campus in Surrey and guides The Telegraph through the vast number of documents accrued by the university.

The files, obtained through a subject access request, give an extraordinary insight into Mr Mitchell’s year of hell. A large number of the 1,465 pages handed over to Mr Mitchell by the university are blacked out, either in their entirety or in part, with details of senders and receivers of messages heavily redacted to protect their identities.

But what they do show is a university desperate to protect its own reputation and convinced that Mr Mitchell, a staunch supporter of the state of Israel whose stance has attracted multiple death threats in recent months, should himself be investigated by the Government’s counter-terrorism Prevent programme.

The reality is Mr Mitchell’s problem – at its core – is to be an outspoken, pro-Zionist student on a British university campus in the 21st century.

“The intimidation was there from the beginning,” he told The Telegraph. “I’ve had so many death threats. Multiple threats to find me, assassinate me, Charlie Kirk me, wear a scarf – keep your neck nice and warm and moist, ready to be slashed.”

But the discovery that the university was keeping tabs on him and reporting him to Prevent – when he believes he is the real victim of all this – has shocked him to the core. “I don’t think it’s at all normal for a university to monitor any type of political student so closely, unless he or she poses a genuine danger. In which case it should be the responsibility of the police. What happened to me is just not normal.”

Life now, at a British university. Antisemitism is normal; death threats to pro-Israel students are normal. Any sign of pro-Israel sentiments, however, must be referred to the counter-terrorism police.

From the university’s submission to Prevent:

Subject: What is the persons ideology or belief of concern if known?

Mr Mitchell has been vocal using his freedom of speech to share views on the Israel / Palestine conflict. He has actively shared that he holds Zionsit & pro-Israel views but that he does not practice the Jewish faith.

The latest commments seen suggest more exteme right-wing views and thoughts which may further be assessed as suspected hate speech.

But – at least some sanity amidst the madness – Prevent weren’t interested:

The university’s referral to Prevent went nowhere. A little over a month later, counter-terrorism police kicked the referral into touch. “There is no evidence to suggest that the subject is developing an extremist mindset in the promotion or advancement of an ideology based on violence, hatred or intolerance,” wrote an officer from Thames Valley Police, his or her name redacted.

The email sent on June 2 knocked back Royal Holloway’s concerns. “There’s no indication that the subject is fascinated with extreme violence, or being radicalised or radicalising anyone else. The subject hasn’t shown a hatred for women or men which includes wanting to harm them due to their Incel ideology. The subject is not being drawn into terrorism or drawing other people into it, and as such it doesn’t meet the Counter-Terrorism criteria for adoption. The case will now be closed…”

Posted in

Leave a Reply