Jo Bartosch at The Critic, on feminists and mass migration. Is it racist to believe women are put at risk by high numbers of undocumented migrant men entering the country?

Last week, the Women’s Policy Centre presented a report to Parliament, Mass Immigration is a Women’s Issue. Its author, lawyer Anna Loutfi, argues that when men from some of the world’s misogynist hellholes arrive in the UK, they do not shed their values in the Channel along with their identity documents. And when such men are housed in areas where they outnumber the local population, women in particular report feeling threatened.

To many of Britain’s professional feminists, voicing such concerns means standing with far-right Christofascists who think women should only be seen in the kitchen and the bedroom. To many grassroots feminist activists, the fear is of conservative Muslim men who think women should only be seen in the kitchen and the bedroom….

As outlined in Loutfi’s report, in Epping, Ethiopian national Hadush Kebatu was convicted of sexually assaulting an adult woman and a teenage girl. In Walsall, Sudanese national Deng Chol Majek murdered 27-year-old Rhiannon Whyte, stabbing her 23 times after following her from the hotel where she worked and he was staying. In Cardiff, asylum seeker Mohammed Abbas broke into a family home and masturbated in front of three females, including two girls.

These cases do not show how common such crimes are among migrants, but they help explain why people may feel unsafe when men they do not know are housed in their communities. Some of those who focus on migrant crime conveniently forget that the home remains the most dangerous place for women in the UK. Whether the crime is rape or battery, the male perpetrator is almost always known to his victim. But although sexual violence by strangers remains thankfully rare, there is no reason to increase the chances of it happening.

Yet earlier this month, women voicing concerns about migrant crime were admonished by a major feminist group for being insufficiently “intersectional”. An astonishingly high-handed blog post by an unnamed professional at the Women’s Resource Centre (WRC) chided respondents to a survey for raising concerns about uncontrolled migration.

The post complained that, horror of horrors, some respondents “suggested that the UK performs relatively well on racial equality”. Moreover, some of the disgraceful plebs made “sweeping, racialised assertions that cast migrant men as inherently dangerous, sexually violent and culturally incompatible with British society”.

But if you can see beyond the politics of the student union bar, it is obvious that men brought up to think of women as second-class citizens might be less inclined to listen when we say No. The Home Office tacitly admits as much. It has produced leaflets explaining that sexual comments to strangers “even as a compliment” constitute harassment; that “both people must say ‘yes’ to sex”; and that cutting or harming a girl’s genitals is illegal and may harm an asylum claim.

Racism can go both ways. British Pakistani men who have preyed on poor white girls have called them “white trash” and “kaffir slags”. To dismiss this as politically inconvenient is disgraceful. It leaves the field to the ethnonationalists, whose rapid rise has been enabled by establishment blind spots and biases. Opening up tough conversations is the only way to tackle racism and the resentments that feed it. People asking legitimate questions must be heard.

The reflex to dismiss concerns as racist has a familiar precedent: women who warned that men identifying as women in female spaces could put them at risk were routinely smeared as backward and bigoted.

One reason so many women don’t call themselves feminists is the attitude of professional finger-waggers at groups like the WRC. Admonishing white women, sneering at them and ignoring evidence that doesn’t fit their worldview makes so many ordinary women, particularly working-class women, feel edged out of a movement that should belong to all of us.

Having been told to shut up by the Owen Joneses of the left and Calvin Robinsons of the right, a lot of women are fed up with being told we don’t deserve to be heard.

The WRC post’s closing paragraph urges white women to “reflect on their own assumptions, learn and challenge their biases”. It is grimly reminiscent of the former head of Edinburgh Rape Crisis, a man who identified as a woman and told survivors of sexual violence they could expect to be challenged about their biases when seeking support. The only reasonable response to such an entreaty is: “After you.”

That former head of the Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre, Mridul Wadhwa, stated that survivors of sexual violence who expressed a desire for single-sex, female-only spaces or support workers were holding “bigoted beliefs” and needed to “reframe their trauma” and “rethink your relationship with prejudice”. After all, “therapy is political”.

Posted in

Leave a Reply