More on Baroness Cass, and her damning evidence before the Conversion Practices Bill scrutiny committee. From the Times:
The paediatrician who led the review of children’s gender services has withdrawn her backing for Labour’s conversion therapy ban, warning that it risked serious unintended consequences for doctors and parents.
Baroness Cass, whose review led to an overhaul of NHS services, was cited by government officials as recently as Sunday night that there was evidence of strong safeguards in the Conversion Practices Bill after concerns were raised by teachers and doctors.
However, giving evidence to a parliamentary committee on Monday, she warned that the legislation put healthcare workers, parents, Wes Streeting, the former health secretary, and even herself at risk of being accused of criminality.
The Times understands that Cass had been angered by perceived attempts to use her endorsement as a defence of the bill.
She told MPs and peers that she had only had 15 minutes to read it before giving her previous support.
In other words, she was pressured into giving her support before she had a chance to examine it properly. She was misled.
Having now examined the proposals, she said: “I unfortunately don’t think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.”
She added: “Having seen the bill, having spoken to many families [who have] emailed me and having spoken to my colleagues, I can’t support the bill in its current form.”
Cass warned that the legislation could expose doctors to vexatious complaints for following the cautious approach to gender dysphoria recommended in her report….
Cass said that another area of significant concern was that parents were being put at risk of prosecution. She said: “Not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child, restricting money if you think they are going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones could fall within the reach of this bill.”
Let’s hope Cass’s testimony finally puts paid to this dreadful bill. They – the bill’s backers, like Bridget Phillipson and Olivia Bailey – were clearly hoping for her support after the Cass Review made her the go-to authority on these matters. And, after having had time to study it, she now realises, quite rightly, that it’s an ill-considered and potentially disastrous piece of legislation.
Leave a Reply