More on the Conversion Practices Bill? Absolutely. Let’s keep the pressure on to get rid of this dreadful piece of legislation..
Julie Bindel in the Telegraph
A broad array of organisations that offer support to youngsters considering “transitioning” to the opposite gender – or reversing such a change – say Labour’s proposed ban on “conversion therapy” could expose them to complaints and even prosecution for providing what they regard as vital support to vulnerable people.
Those behind such groups say the draft Conversion Practices Bill – which The Telegraph is campaigning against – would have a chilling effect on therapists, parents and organisations, if it becomes law. Even complaints that come to nothing, whether made to the police, the Charity Commission or regulators, would be enough to make many people reluctant to take the risk.
Michael Kerr is the founder of Detransition Pathway UK, a support network for people considering, or in the midst of, returning to living as their biological sex, having previously transitioned to the opposite gender. Kerr, a “detransitioner” himself, reverted to his birth gender last year, having lived as a woman since the age of 27. The 34-year-old fears that he and others involved in the organisation could be criminalised for giving advice to those who approach them because they are deeply unhappy living as the opposite sex.
“Detransitioners must be able to question their past decisions, discuss the circumstances that led them to transition and receive support without fear that those conversations could be interpreted as prohibited conversion practices,” he says….
Anna Hutchinson is a clinical psychologist and director of the Integrated Psychology Clinic, which provides psychological assessments and interventions for young people and others. Hutchinson had previously raised concerns about the now-closed Tavistock gender clinic. When she gave evidence to the parliamentary committee set up to scrutinise the Conversion Practices Bill, activists instantly labelled her a supporter of trans conversion for simply critiquing the practice of automatically “affirming” those who state they are trans, and for saying it is the job of a therapist to question assumptions and scrutinise evidence.
Hutchinson also warned that the draft bill’s explanatory notes leave it to the courts to decide what constitutes “harm” or “abuse” that would be outlawed under the legislation. “Feasibly, we could have a client who subjectively experiences therapy as alarming and distressing, and then it would be up to the courts to decide whether that was harm or abuse,” she said.
The parent-run Bayswater Support Group, founded in 2019, provides help and support to families trying to protect a child from the harms of gender ideology. It is also being “targeted and maliciously accused of conversion”, a spokesman says. Members engage with government departments, educational bodies and health regulators, as well as campaigning for restrictions on “trans-inclusive” education in schools.
Hundreds of families have turned to it after being failed by professionals and institutions, the spokesman says, adding: “If this bill goes into law, this sanctuary we provide will become a direct target for activist lawfare. This would risk criminalising the parent volunteers who run Bayswater, making the lifeline we provide unviable.”
Other organisations providing support services have similar fears. Kate Barker, chief executive of the LGB Alliance, which runs the UK’s only dedicated helpline for young gay people, believes the legislation could lead to the service being shut down and its volunteers sent to prison simply for asserting that it’s OK to be gay.
It’s a prospect she finds “horrifying”, but Barker firmly believes that if this bill becomes law, this will be a very real risk. As drafted, the bill would put any conversation that does not go along with the notion that camp gay men must be really women trapped in the wrong body (or that butch lesbians are really men) within the legal definition of a “conversion practice”. One clause states that “any conduct” intended to cause a person to believe they do not have a transgender identity is a conversion practice.
Barker says the bill is supported by trans activists who are “angry, authoritarian and homophobic”. The draft law “seeks to destroy individuals and institutions who will not play along with the fiction that children can be ‘born in the wrong body’ or that a straight man can be a lesbian, simply because he declares it to be so”.
Essentially it’s a trans activists’ charter.
Maya Forstater, chief executive of Sex Matters, says she expects her organisation to be reported to the police for its failure to agree that men can be women. “This is what the bill requires everyone to do, on pain of criminal sanction,” she says. “If this authoritarian bill becomes law, it will be the death of free speech in the UK.”
And it’s blatantly homophobic: transing away the gay.
Leave a Reply