From photographer Marcella Hackbardt’s series “True Confessionals”:

Confessional1
Santo Spirito, Florence, 2015.

Confessional2
Basilica di Santa Sabina all’Aventino, Rome, 2014.

Confessional4
Basilica di San Marco, Florence, 2015.

Confessional5
San Simpliciano, Milan, 2015.

Confessional8
Duomo, Parma, 2015.

Confessional9
San Pietro, Parma, 2015.

The confessional is a special place in any Catholic Church, but in Marcella Hackbardt’s series “True Confessionals,” it takes on a distinct significance. Centered in their frames and largely shown in churches empty of people, Hackbardt’s confessionals strike viewers not as merely one feature among many in the architecture of faith, but as a theatrical space that services some fundamental human need—one that possibly transcends any particular religious dogma. As Hackbardt sees them, they’re “a powerful metaphor for self-perception and the examination of conscience.”

For someone brought up in the less intrusive and more relaxed practices of the Anglican church, the whole business of going to confession always struck me as decidedly unBritish. The relation between a chap and his conscience is, frankly, no one else's damn business – particularly not some ghastly unctuous man dressed up in gowns and silly hats, who is clearly having considerable problems with the whole business of celibacy anyway. Unpleasant echoes of Maoist self-criticism sessions and all that, too. Either you're honest – which would be humiliating and pathetic - or you lie – which encourages the kind of hypocrisy which is at the heart of so much Catholicism.

Still, nice pics…

Posted in

3 responses to “Italian Confessionals”

  1. DM Avatar
    DM

    Ha, ha (your comment). I remember when I first went to one myself. Couldn’t figure out what was appropriate to say. So I lied. A small lie. For the price of a few Hail Marys. But I still felt uncomfortable.

    Like

  2. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    Terrifying memories for me. I still remember the opening prayer. I once stole a set of 9 bottles of paint, so I went to three confessionals and confessed that I stole three bottles each time. Just to cover it all.

    Like

  3. clazy8 Avatar
    clazy8

    A “ghastly unctuous man” &c.? It’s not the voice of a confident atheism. And the remark about conscience is uncharacteristically facile. Perhaps I wouldn’t be offended if I hadn’t been raised Catholic in the deep US South. Or if I had been raised Catholic in Europe. Funny thing: I don’t believe I would have given the language any thought except that reading Milton long ago drew a spark from the ashes of my own Christianity. Ironic, no? It remains only a spark, but surrounded by so much darkness, it casts a meaningful light. No, I’m not offering to share it.

    Like

Leave a reply to clazy8 Cancel reply