Janice Turner in the Times – The battle is on to stop gender extremism by the back door:
What strange political theatre is playing out in Westminster’s committee room 3. Aren’t we all against cruel conversion practices intended to change a person’s sexuality or gender identity? Why is this proposed legislation, on the to-do list of every PM since Theresa May, so toxic, divisive and hard to get over the line?
First, because the draft bill is a bait and switch. It draws support by citing terrible acts lesbians and gay men suffered in the past: forced ingestion of poisons, “corrective rape”, being held down during religious exorcism, electro-aversion therapy and kidnap. Yet all these are crimes under existing laws and, thankfully, now vanishingly rare. Instead the bill criminalises the behaviour and speech of ordinary people, especially families with gender-questioning teenagers.
I talk to Elisabeth whose daughter, Grace, 16, grew withdrawn during lockdown when she was obsessively online. A “nerdy”, highly intelligent girl on the autistic spectrum, she suddenly wrote her parents a letter saying she wished to be called by a male name and pronouns. (Five of Grace’s six closest friends began identifying as boys at this time.)
While the school went along with this, without Elisabeth’s consent, she and her husband tried to remain neutral, calling Grace by a family nickname: “but she hated us for not affirming her and using pronouns. Online groups constantly told her we were abusive, and didn’t love her.” This was a volatile, traumatic period for the family.
Under the proposed bill’s vague definitions, Grace, her teachers or an outsider, such as another parent, could have reported Elisabeth for committing an “abusive conversion practice”, causing “serious alarm or distress to the individual which has a substantial adverse effect on their day-to-day activities.”
This could trigger the bill’s most draconian power, a “conversion practice protection order” (CPPO), which could remove Grace from her family. Failure to comply would carry a maximum five-year prison term and an unlimited fine.
Yet when Grace found a part-time job working with animals, which took her offline, her gender fixation slowly faded and she is now flourishing at university. (All her friends, except one, also desisted.) At 16, she was binding her breasts and planning to take testosterone but now she says “my mother saved me, without her I’d be dead in a ditch”.
Elisabeth, one of hundreds of alarmed parents who have submitted evidence to the committee, says: “Who benefits when a vulnerable child is separated from her loving family? That is what this bill will do. It is deeply flawed and sinister.”
That this bill would criminalise speech acts such as misgendering in families, schools, organisations and workplaces, is not a glitch but a feature. Because the bill is not a response to a real-world problem: in over three years a government conversion practices helpline received 371 calls with only 29 related to potential conversion practices, while most reported “incorrect” pronoun use.
So where’s this coming from? Who’s pushing the bill?
Notably, the bill was not initiated by the Ministry of Justice (like the “upskirting” law) or the Home Office (female genital mutilation law), but emanates from the ministry for equalities, specifically, the Equality Hub, an internal group of civil servants deeply enmeshed with LGBT charities such as Stonewall, Mermaids and Galop….
Battle-hardened feminist campaigners believe LGBT activists are using the bill as a back door through which it can vandalise recent victories, such as the reaffirmation of sex-based rights by the Supreme Court. Bailey’s bill would enshrine “gender identity” in law for the first time, a key demand of self-ID.
And its definition of trans includes those who identify as “neither male nor female or … not solely male or female”. It would be a criminal act to tell someone who claims to be non-binary that it is scientifically impossible they have no biological sex….
“It is time,” said one MP, “the Labour Party consciously uncoupled from Stonewall.”
And the civil service – the so-called equality hub. This whole business is so obviously a last-ditch effort by trans ideologues to undo all the advances we’ve made recently in turning back the horrors of the gender cult.
Leave a Reply