Dave Rich on the Byline Times affair, and their “unmasking” of Habibi:

Crucially, Byline Times have not shown a single example of Habibi posting something that is untrue or inaccurate – and that, surely, is what matters. They even state that they do not take a position “on whether or not the content of the attacks or criticisms is either accurate or legitimate.” In other words, even if someone makes an entirely accurate and legitimate criticism of a public figure for saying something antisemitic, this counts, for Byline Times, as “disinformation”. It’s Orwellian….

Other people who Byline Times reveal, in shocked tones, that Habibi frequently posted about include David Miller, Chris Williamson and Jeremy Corbyn. Again – so what?

David Miller and Chris Williamson co-present Palestine Declassified on the Iranian state broadcaster Press TV: by some distance the most antisemitic media produced in this country. Jeremy Corbyn led the Labour Party into the moral and legal disgrace of unlawful discrimination against its Jewish members. They are exactly the kind of people who an anti-antisemitism campaigner would target, not because they criticise Israel, but because of their antisemitism.

This is what Byline Times completely ignores. Anti-Jewish hatred, in word and deed, is running at feverishly high levels. There have been terrorist attacks, arsons and stabbings of Jews. According to police figures, a Jewish person is nine times more likely to be the victim of a religious hate crime than a person of any other religious background. You wouldn’t know any of this from reading these two articles. Instead, you get an academic from Leeds University, Professor Paul Wragg, complaining about “reasonably expressed criticism of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict” being branded as antisemitism. It leaves you with the impression that antisemitism isn’t worth all this attention, and the online fuss is entirely confected.

But Gary Lineker’s posting of a ‘Zionist’ rat was not “reasonably expressed criticism of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict”: it was an antisemitic motif. Nor was it reasonable criticism of Israel when Louis Theroux claimed that “post-Holocaust Jewish exceptionalism” is a “role model” for Victor Orban and Donald Trump; or when Nadia Sawalha defended Theroux from what she called the “group of people” who “live by their pound of flesh rule”; or when, a week after two synagogues were targets for arson, Zack Polanski queried whether British Jews are confusing a “perception of unsafety” with “actual unsafety”. Dismissing all of this as simply people criticising Israel is deeply disingenuous.

The government is throwing money at this Byline Times, but all they’ve come up with is an investigation exposing nothing but a man dedicated to providing us with information – which no one else is providing – on the swamp of antisemitism from Islamist and hard-left sources in the UK. It’s bad, apparently, because….well, because Jews. Because if we put Jews and conspiracies together, everyone gets the picture.

Posted in

Leave a Reply