Editorial in the Times this morning on the Conversion Practices Bill – “The bill is a sinister, shoddy and unnecessary piece of work, a Trojan horse for the widely discredited cause of the extreme trans lobby”.
Should a father who refuses to call his son or daughter “they” face criminal prosecution and a prison sentence? Or a mother who throws away hormones that were obtained by her child from an unregulated source on the internet? Or a GP who insists on accurately recording the biological sex of a man who identifies as a woman? Or a priest who speaks to children about Christian values and their role in relationships? In a sane society, the answer would be no. Indeed polling shows that most Britons would oppose such a blatant attack on the sovereignty of the family, professional integrity and freedom of expression.
Unfortunately, this sanity does not extend to the government, which is pushing forward a bill that in its own way is as dangerous, slapdash and otiose as the now-defunct assisted dying one. The Conversion Practices Bill is a legal abomination, one that uses a sledgehammer to crack a nut: the thankfully rare number of cases in which coercion is used to persuade gay people to change their orientation. Under pressure from the extreme trans lobby, the proposed law has morphed into a Trojan horse for their widely discredited cause.
Most Britons are unaware of the bill, which is currently before a joint committee of the Commons and Lords. Intended to ban extreme practices such as electric shock treatment and exorcism, an anti-conversion bill was originally a Conservative idea but was deemed by them to be unworkable. Existing law already outlaws such practices, but Labour resurrected the concept of bespoke sanctions in its manifesto in 2024.
Born during Labour’s unfathomable flirtation with trans ideology, the policy extends coercion and abuse to include comments, commands or actions that might distress a child questioning either their sexuality or gender. Parents, teachers, therapists, even classmates, would be at the mercy of children and activists able to trigger private criminal prosecutions. Maximum sentence: five years. Their “crime” would be the refusal to sign up automatically to a child’s belief that he or she inhabits the wrong body and instead offer an alternative interpretation of their feelings. By embedding gender transition in a law intended to combat anti-gay discrimination, the trans lobby and its allies in Labour have repurposed it to remove legal protections covering those who dispute their beliefs. Opposition to the bill has come from the Anglican and Catholic churches, some gay groups, free speech campaigners, the Conservatives and Reform UK.
This week, Baroness Cass, whose review in 2024 led to an overhaul of NHS gender reassignment practices, including a ban on the prescription of puberty blockers for minors, withdrew her support for the bill. Having been bounced into backing the initial concept by the government, she now believes it threatens medical professionals seeking to help youngsters with the possibility of prosecution.
Four years ago, the government set up a helpline for alleged victims of conversion abuse, expecting up to 15,000 calls a year. The latest tender for the service cites as few as 300 calls, some of which are thought to involve the use of an unwanted pronoun. Hysteria over conversion practices has breathed new life into the trans hysteria that drove Sir Keir Starmer to state that a woman can have a penis. Andy Burnham should restore sanity, kill this bill off and avoid the same embarrassment.
One of the more extraordinary aspects of this ridiculous business is that Stonewall were so heavily involved. Stonewall! Discredited everywhere else, but able to cling on thanks to a selection of idiots in the Labour Party.
Leave a Reply