They must have interesting editorial conferences over at the Guardian's shiny new offices near Kings Cross. Lat week at CiF they published a piece by Ros Wynne-Jones, warning of the prospect of renewed north-south conflict five years after the peace treaty was signed, and describing the desperate scenes in the Chad refugee camps for the displaced and forgotten victims of the Darfur conflict:

People there are unsure whether their fate is worse than death. Militias surround these supposed places of safety, and women are raped walking for firewood; rations are meagre; and the hope of returning home diminishes with every passing year.

And now we have another CiF piece, a response to Ros Wynne-Jones, from one Ghazi Salahuddin Atabani. Who he? Well, yes, he's not a regular CiF contributor. This is his first piece. He is, in fact, "an adviser to the president of Sudan, and leader of the parliamentary majority". That would be president of Sudan Omar al-Bashir – the man issued with an arrest warrant by the International Criminal Court for crimes against humanity, and the man principally responsible for the genocidal campaign in Darfur. Atabani doesn't like Wynne-Jones' piece, you'll be surprised to hear. It's based on "outdated stereotypes."

Well, it's always good to hear the other point of view. Next week at CiF: Khieu Samphan, Cambodian head of state under Pol Pot, argues that the current Khmer Rouge trials are based on a misunderstanding of the true revolutionary history of Democratic Kampuchea, based as they are on outdated stereotypes… 

Posted in

4 responses to “Outdated Stereotypes”

  1. I Adam Avatar
    I Adam

    Snarky and highly misinformed, Mick. And typical of the ‘intellectual’ fascism that dominates the Western (emphasis) mainstream and social network media ‘discourse’about Sudan: i.e. dare say anything different than the conventional discourse and you get blackballed. How very sad; haven’t you learned anything from the run-up to the Iraq war????
    Crowd out the activists-journalists like Ros and yourself – and crowd-in Sudanese voices who know their country best (naturally) and the best way to solve their issues.
    Ibrahim Adam
    El Fasher, North Darfur,
    Sudan
    Opinion is no substitute for facts:
    “No time to be deceived, brothers you should know and not believe” – Ride Natty Ride, the late, great Robert Nesta Marley

    Like

  2. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Hmm. Not clear what I’m supposed to be highly misinformed about.
    “I shot the sheriff, but I didn’t shoot no deputy”. That’s another one from the late great Robert Nesta Marley.

    Like

  3. I Adam Avatar
    I Adam

    Here’s the best Bob song that sums up Brits, Americans and other Westerners banging on – with just a very facile view – on Sudan:
    “They’ve got so much things to say right now, they’ve got so much things to say, wah-wah-wah, they’re blabbering all the time, so much things to say, rumour without humour, they don’t know what their doing yeah!”
    So Much Things to Say – Exodus, released 1977.
    Bob called out/saw the likes of you – arrogant, snarky woefully under-informed, self-righteous Westerners” thirty three years ago……same old.
    Honestly, writing about Sudan, after gleaning a couple of shallow UK or US journalists’ reports on Sudan: bet you still can’t even name the four largest towns in Sudan.
    The point of my two replies, Mick:
    save your sarcasm and silly posts like your one above – and let us SUDANESE sort our own issues out.
    Not much to ask, is it, Mick?
    I Adam
    Sudan

    Like

  4. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Well you’ve certainly done a great job so far. How many dead in the north-south civil war? How many dead in Darfur? Keep up the good work! Or are all those bodies just in the imagination of us arrogant Westerners?

    Like

Leave a comment