As the Iranian protesters continue their heroic struggle against the police state that's being brutally imposed on them, where will you find defenders of the appalling Ahmadinejad? Why, in the Guardian of course, with Seumas Milne:

'They have elected a Labour government," a Savoy diner famously declared on the night of Britain's election landslide in 1945. "The country will never stand for it." From the evidence so far coming out of Iran, something similar seems to be happening on the streets of Tehran – and in the western capitals just as desperate to see the back of Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

Of course the movement behind opposition candidate Mir Hossein Mousavi spreads far beyond the capital's elite, as did the supporters of Winston Churchill against Clement Attlee. In Iran, it includes large sections of the middle class, students and the secular. But a similar misreading of their own social circles for the country at large appears to have convinced the opposition's supporters that it can only have lost last Friday's election through fraud.

That is also reflected in the western media, whose cameras focus so lovingly on Tehran's gilded youth and for whom Ahmadinejad is nothing but a Holocaust-denying fanatic. The other Ahmadinejad, who is seen to stand up for the country's independence, expose elite corruption on TV and use Iran's oil wealth to boost the incomes of the poor majority, is largely invisible abroad.

While Mousavi promised market reforms and privatisation, more personal freedom and better relations with the west, the president increased pensions and public sector wages and handed out cheap loans. So it's hardly surprising that Ahmadinejad should have a solid base among the working class, the religious, small town and rural poor – or that he might have achieved a similar majority to that of his first election in 2005. That's what one of the few genuinely independent polls (the US-based Ballen-Doherty survey) predicted last month, when the Times reported Ahmadinejad was "expected to win"…

But such details have got lost as the pressure has built in Tehran for a "green revolution" amid unsubstantiated claims that the election was stolen. The strongest evidence appears to be some surprising regional results and the speed of the official announcement, triggered by Mousavi's declaration that he was the winner before the polls closed. But most official figures don't look so implausible – Mousavi won Tehran, for instance, by 2.2m votes to 1.8m – and it's hard to believe that rigging alone could account for the 11 million-vote gap between the main contenders.

If Ahamdinejad was in fact the winner, then there is an attempted coup going on in Tehran right now, and it is being led by Mousavi and his western-backed supporters. 

Yep – the only coup going on in Iran is by Mousavi and his western-backed supporters. Nothing to see here. Lets move on to more congenial topics…

Meanwhile, resistance and wider violence have been growing again in Iraq, as US occupation troops pull back from the cities. And in Afghanistan, far from winding down the occupation, Obama is escalating the conflict as promised….

Naturally, Milne's piece meets with approval from a section of the progressive Guardian readership…

Sweet article.

It seems to me that the idea is to make Iran look bad so that an attack on its nuclear infrastructure will provoke only mild rebuke. The fact that a lot of the twitter stuff appears to be coming from Israeli spammers makes that more likely.

Posted in

6 responses to “Ahmadinejad as Clement Attlee”

  1. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    Concerning the Ballen-Doherty polls, let’s see how the poll-takers themselves summarized it at http://www.terrorfreetomorrow.org/articlenav.php?id=5
    “While our uncensored poll shows incumbent President Ahmadinejad in the lead with a plurality of support, the survey also reveals that a second round run off against his closest challenger, Mir Hussein Moussavi, is likely.”
    Everyone leaves out the last part.

    Like

  2. DaninVan Avatar
    DaninVan

    Lots of punditry here…http://sandbox.blog-city.com/iranian_turmoil.htm
    And no, I haven’t read it all…:)

    Like

  3. Bob-B Avatar
    Bob-B

    People like Milne hate the West and support anyone who shares their hatred, no matter how crazy and despotic. It’s only logical.

    Like

  4. Nicole S Avatar
    Nicole S

    ‘The fact that a lot of the twitter stuff appears to be coming from Israeli spammers makes that more likely.’ I knew it. It’s them pesky Jews again.

    Like

  5. observer Avatar
    observer

    How would they know that the Twitter s are coming from Israel?

    Like

  6. SnoopyTheGoon Avatar

    I, personally, loved this one: “Maybe it’s simply about time we learned to stop trying see our values reflected in these cultures..?”
    Yeah, the prevalent line of the Guardianistas today is that we shouldn’t expect all these red, brown and yellow folks to understand them complicated Western values, irrelevant to their case anyways…

    Like

Leave a reply to observer Cancel reply