Can you spot the contradiction in this headline?

More faith schools are planned in an effort to integrate minorities

Thousands of Muslim children will be educated in new state faith schools under radical plans to extend state education to Britain’s minority religions.

The move comes amid growing concern that a generation of British Muslim children, whose parents may speak poor English or be poorly integrated in British society, could grow up in segregated communities.

The move would give the Government greater control over Muslim schools at a time when questions are being raised about whether some are adequately preparing children for life in Britain.

It would also respond to the huge demand among Muslim parents for their children to attend madrassas and after-school Muslim education classes in mosques and to ensure that their children get a proper grounding in their faith.

Given the government’s record on dealing with British Muslims – which is, to assume that they form a monolithic community whose views can best be articulated by the most extreme, and to ignore any warning signs about the influence of hardliners – I don’t see why we should find it in any way reassuring that they plan to take greater control in their education. And I certainly don’t see why the rest of us should finance the rote learning of the Koran, never mind whatever else they might learn (see previous post).

The separation of religion from education should surely be the foundation of the school system in a modern liberal society like Britain. If people want to spend their own money on sending their children to independent religious academies, there’s little we can do about it, but the state should play no part. To plan an increase in state faith schools is to move in completely the wrong direction. I kind of hoped that with Blair gone we might see Labour distancing itself from all this, but apparently not.

Posted in

5 responses to “New Faith Schools”

  1. DaninVan Avatar
    DaninVan

    Why does this ‘question’ keep coming back?
    Parents (and religious group non-parents) pay for the secular, state run school system AS WELL AS their own parochial schools. Asking the far larger general populations’ taxpayers to help pay for the religious schools seems logical and fair…as long as the parochial schools are teaching the state’s school curriculum (as well as the religious and cultural content).
    Two cornerstones would have to be universally administered examinations, and an absolute ban on ‘hate’ content. I’d also add that any and all teachers should have to be state certified (for qualifications to be teaching the curriculum). An exception would be home schooling. In that instance, tax relief for covering the cost of some tutoring might be justified (Math for instance).
    The quoted figure of 63% of British-Jewish kids being parochially schooled floored me! Can we assume that may well be as a result of systemic antisemitism in G.B.?

    Like

  2. Dom Avatar
    Dom

    Why not have a flat out educational voucher system? Instead of the state paying schools, and then telling parents where to send their children, just pay the parents directly. Parents, of course, can choose private, even religious, schools, if they please.

    Like

  3. Laban Tall Avatar

    “I certainly don’t see why the rest of us should finance the rote learning of the Koran”
    But a lot of us don’t see why we should finance a whole lot of other nagombi which our children are ‘taught’ using our money. Given the State takes 42% of gross national product, why should it only offer a secular education ? Especially when secularists aren’t the ones having the kids !

    Like

  4. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    DV – yes, that 63% surprised me, but I think it’s more down to what Jewish parents think of state education. Whatever you may have heard about anti-semitism here, it’s really not bad enough to keep Jewish kids out of state schools.

    Like

  5. DaninVan Avatar
    DaninVan

    Dom; personally I don’t have any problem with your suggestion, however you’d be taking on the Education Establishment. They’re a powerful and influential segment and they HATE the voucher concept! …at least they do here in Canada where we have similar issues.

    Like

Leave a reply to Mick H Cancel reply