I think Barabara Ellen’s got it about right on that Unicef report:

Neglected? Deprived? Those living below the poverty line are one thing, but the majority of UK adolescents are, if anything, spoiled brats. I would challenge anyone to fill a small car park with British 15-year-olds (from any social class) who don’t own a mobile phone. It is also debatable whether our children are as ‘disenfranchised’ as depicted in the report. At one point, we’re breathlessly informed that ‘only 81 per cent of them really like school’ (only?). But never mind that. When listening to British children talking about the spiritual wasteland that is their existence, those nice Unicef people with their clipboards failed to include the most crucial factor of all – the contrary bolshie nature of the people they were talking to; the fact that British teenagers have always loved nothing more than to pose, bitch, rebel, slag everything and everyone off, and blow endless anti-establishment raspberries.

Indeed, British teenagers are, have always been, by nature, rebellious, stroppy, and a lot less interested in being fair than they are in being interesting. Which to my mind is much less creepy and disturbing than the thought of all those sucky-up kids from Holland and Sweden (henceforth known as the apple-polishing nations) chirruping away about how much they respect their elders. Bearing this in mind, this was the only possible result for this study.

Unlike their Dutch or Swedish counterparts, British children were never going to answer such questions as ‘Are your contemporaries kind and helpful?’ with po-faced sincerity; to piously and publicly abhor the idea of sex, drugs, and other ‘bad behaviour’; and pour anything other than molten scorn upon the status quo. Indeed, the vast majority of British adolescents are as they always were, as most of us were – vile, stroppy, preternaturally sarcastic ingrates, who would doubtless be labelled dangerous, disaffected sociopaths in any other European country. And this is supposed to be a bad thing?

The UK, in fact, does especially badly at “risk behaviours”, where we languish at the foot of the rankings by “a considerable distance”. Risk is bad, apparently.

Risk behaviours considered in the study include smoking, being drunk, using cannabis, fighting and bullying, and sexual behaviour.

Only about a third of young people eat fruit daily.

Shocking.

Posted in

2 responses to “Preternaturally Sarcastic Ingrates”

  1. whatsforsupper Avatar
    whatsforsupper

    Barbara Ellen may be right that our young people are more likely to express dissatisfaction than others, but otherwise she is quite wrong. To state the obvious, young people are people, that is the same as everyone else, only younger, maybe spottier and in the grip of stronger urges. We can make some allowances for their stroppy behaviour but we don’t have to admire it. After all, who’s paying for their nikes and electronic gadgetry? The tendency in this country to set teenagers apart and treat them as if they have been temporarily abducted by aliens is another form of ageism, as well as an abdication of responsibility.

    Like

  2. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    There are two separate issues, I think. One is that British youngsters are far more likely to express dissatisfaction than their European counterparts. Then there’s the issue of whether that bolshiness is a good thing or not. Barbara Ellen I suppose does imply that she thinks it’s a good thing – and you clearly disagree – but I don’t think it affects her main point, which is that such attitudes go some way to explaining why British kids come out of the Unicef report so badly.

    Like

Leave a reply to Mick H Cancel reply