• So many organisations have delayed following the law about women-only spaces by saying they were waiting for guidance. Well, now they're getting it:

    Schools, hospitals, leisure centres and cinemas will be told to ban trans women from using single-sex spaces including lavatories and changing rooms under equalities guidance to be submitted to ministers this month.

    The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) is understood to have rejected demands from campaigners to water down rules that would restrict the ability of trans people to access services of their chosen gender.

    The statutory guidance will spell out that transgender competitors can be excluded from single-sex sporting competitions and that it would be reasonable for a woman to object to the presence of a transgender woman if she will be getting undressed or in a vulnerable situation.

    The guidance applies to any organisation that provides services to the public.

    Clear enough?

    Shops and gyms will be included in its scope but the guidance also extends to government departments, the NHS and prisons. It covers private organisations or charities if they are providing a public service, for example a private care home providing care on behalf of a council.

    The EHRC will submit its updated guidance to Bridget Phillipson, the women and equalities minister, before the end of the month. It is believed Phillipson will approve the guidance as long as it is in line with the law. It will then be laid before parliament.

  • We're back north of the border, where they do things differently:

    Staff at Scotland’s youth gender clinic say they are struggling to deal with surging numbers of children who identify as neither male nor female.

    A warning about the rise in “non-binary” patients was raised as part of a review into the impact of government spending on trans healthcare. However, workers at the Sandyford clinic in Glasgow highlighted a lack of guidance on how they should be looked after.

    One health professional revealed that some young “non-binary” patients who say they do not belong to either gender still request sex hormones that would either feminise or masculinise them.

    It's almost as though, rather than genuine problems, these patients are anxious young adolescents in the grip of a social contagion about not conforming to rigid sexist stereotypes, so have come to the delusional belief that they must be non-binary or trans or whatever.

    The employee said: “We’re following a 2012 protocol that doesn’t talk at all about non-binary people, which is actually becoming a much bigger proportion of our cases.

    “And [there are] non-binary people asking for hormones, but of course hormones are only either feminising or masculinising. So how does that fit for a person who identifies as non-binary?”

    It doesn't. It's all nonsense.

    Those who do not conform to male or female categories have become “more difficult to manage” because of the lack of guidance and NHS pathways for them, another member of the youth team told the review.

    “Over the last ten years, obviously there’s been a big increase in the number of people presenting [with] gender non-conforming identities … we’ve really struggled to think about how we deal with that in a fair way,” the staff member said.

    Over the last three years SNP ministers have spent £9 million on gender identity healthcare and the review was commissioned to assess the impact on services. A total of £3.6 million was apportioned to lead to improvements.

    One consultant who has worked in gender healthcare told The Times they had encountered patients who shifted genders depending on how they felt on different days. “We have got into a position where we are enabling people to deny reality and we have reinforced delusional behaviours,” the consultant said.

    Well yes. Exactly. And who's behind all this?

    According to the review the Scottish government funding had seen improvements to staffing and “deepened collaborations with LGBT Youth Scotland”. Earlier this year the Scottish Conservatives called for all public funding to be withdrawn from this charity after concerns were raised that it was “normalising” self-harm. The Scottish Charity Regulator investigated fears about its stance on cutting with blades but was satisfied action had been taken to address any issues.

    Of course. LGBT Youth Scotland. A reminder, from Janice Turner last year:

    In 2009 eight men were convicted of running the most depraved child sex ring in Scottish history. Besides sharing the worst categories of dark web paedophile abuse, they fantasised about gaining access to a real child.

    One of them, James Rennie, was trusted to babysit his godson, the child of university friends. So, starting when the boy was three months old, Rennie filmed himself sexually abusing the child then shared videos with the other men, even suggesting it would be “hotter” if they came along to join in. Rennie, who was given a life sentence, was the head of LGBT Youth Scotland (LGBTYS), joining the charity in 1997 and becoming chief executive in 2003. Rennie’s trial heard that he often accessed his special sex ring Hotmail account “kplover” (kiddy porn lover) at work.

    You’d expect the Scottish Charity Regulator to launch an inquiry to ascertain whether Rennie had access to vulnerable young people, or how being led for years by a predatory paedophile had affected office culture and safeguarding. But it did not. Nor did the police forces that had exposed the sex ring investigate LGBTYS. Both accepted its internal investigation which concluded that everything was fine.

    Even more extraordinary, seven months after Rennie was jailed, BBC Children in Need decided to award, for the first time, a grant of £24,000 to LGBTYS. The charity turns down 90 per cent of good causes that apply for funding, yet money raised by BBC viewers was given to a charity whose outgoing chief executive sexually abused a baby….

  • https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

    The Pritzkers are one of the wealthiest families in America. JB's cousin is Jennifer (born James) Pritzker, "the first and only openly transgender billionaire", and a leading advocate of transgenderism – what Jennifer Bilek prefers to call "synthetic sex identities".

    Added:

    https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

  • Ah yes.

    Britain's homelessness minister increased the rent on a house she owns by hundreds of pounds, allegedly "within weeks" of the previous tenants' contract ending.

    The i Paper, external reported that four tenants who rented a house owned by Rushanara Ali in East London were sent an email last November giving them four months' notice that their lease would not be renewed.

    It says the property was re-listed shortly after the tenants moved out, at a rent that was £700 a month higher.

    Ali is Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Homelessness and Rough Sleeping. A spokesman said: "Rushanara takes her responsibilities seriously and complied with all relevant legal requirements."

    Update: She's resigned. Remaining in post would be a "distraction from the ambitious work of this government".

  • From the JC:

    A number of European picture agencies have told German media that they will no longer use images from a Gazan photographer after an investigation by Süddeutsche Zeitung (SZ) found that some of his depictions of hunger in the Strip were staged.

    In a documentary about his work during the war, Anas Zayed Fteiha was filmed taking pictures of civilians queuing for aid.

    From the perspective of his lens, the photo showed a crowd of Gazans with empty bowls outstretched, appearing to be jostling for food.

    However, a wide shot from the film published by SZ revealed that there were no supplies behind Fteiha as he took the photo and that he was not at a food bank at the time.

    Questions have also been raised about the photographer’s independence, given that he works for Turkey’s state-run agency Anadolu and has previously posted anti-Israel statements on social media.

    These included an illustration of him in a press vest and helmet surrounded by the domes of Al-Aqsa Mosque on the Temple Mount and underscored by the caption “Free Palestine”, as well as a video clip bearing the caption “f*** Israel”.

    The images he took were distributed by Anadolu and were used by outlets including New York Magazine, CNN and BBC News, according to German paper Bild.

    Well who would have thought? I'm shocked.

    But, for the defence:

    Christopher Resch, the Middle East spokesman for Reporters Without Borders, defended Fteiha’s work, saying: “More context should have been provided for the image, but that doesn't make the situation any better.

    "That's how many photographers around the world work. Of course, it's always about the effect.

    "I don't think it's reprehensible if a photographer instructs people to stand here and there with their pots. As long as it roughly describes reality.”

    "Roughly describes reality"?? You mean, the reality that the photographer wants to convey, not the actual reality. The photographer decides what the reality is, then manipulates the scene to convey that "reality". That's not journalism; that's propaganda. It's the same excuse used by those who published pictures of children with cerebral palsy and the like as a demonstration of the starvation in Gaza: it conveys their anti-Israel message very well no doubt, but it's lying.

    He also urged caution about suggesting that photographers working in Gaza are controlled by Hamas, “otherwise, the impression easily arises that it's propaganda or a deliberate fabrication, and that has consequences”.

    In the public's perception, these photographers are then placed close to combatants. That's brutally dangerous,” he said. “Once a name is circulating, these people receive death threats every second.”

    So we should happily accept these staged photographs to protect the photographers? But of course he's conceding the point here: everything that comes out of Gaza is controlled by Hamas, under threat of death. We just have to pretend that's not true.

  • https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

    Worth reading Carole Hooven's full thread.

    Lancet editor Richard Horton has quite a history…

    • on Covid, publishing that group letter organised by the zoologist Peter Daszak on the origins of the Sars-CoV-2 coronavirus  ‘strongly condemn[ing] conspiracy theories’ about a lab leak, and praising China on state-owned broadcaster China Central Television for how ‘tremendously decisively’ the Chinese Communist party had handled the pandemic.
    • on MMR, publishing Andrew Wakefield – not retracted for twelve years.
    •  publishing a letter in Lancet in 2014 from a number of pro-Palestinian activists which the Israeli Ministry of Health characterised as “bordering on blood libel".
    • the case of Sir Roy Meadows.
    •  railing against "the axis of Anglo-American imperialism" at a 2006 rally in Manchester.

    Still editor-in-chief though.

    Added, from Marcus Evans:

    In 2019, after resigning as governor of @TaviAndPort [the Tavistock Clinic] ,@TheLancet contacted me for an interview about my decision. I raised concerns about the Trust’s promotion of unevidenced, sometimes irreversible medical interventions on children, despite staff and parent complaints. The journal initially showed interest.

    I am grateful to you @jonkay, for editing a piece I wrote for @Quillette, but The Lancet editor informed me the article was dropped without explanation.

    Disappointing from a journal that should prioritize medical ethics over ideology. Like the @BMA, many medical institutions have lost their moral compass, and public confidence is declining.

  • https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

    If you don't know about the Giggle v Tickle case, this from Jo Bartosch is a good place to start.

    Added:

    https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

  • https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

  • North Korea's dog days (previously) are not going well:

    A state-run dog meat restaurant in North Korea has been shut down after about 10 customers suffered food poisoning during the peak summer dining season, with authorities blaming the incident on inadequate water and electricity supplies rather than just poor sanitation.

    The outbreak occurred at a restaurant operated by Sunchon city’s commercial department in South Pyongan province during sambok, the traditional three hottest days of summer when dog meat consumption typically soars. All customers who ate at the establishment on July 12 developed severe symptoms within hours, including stomach pain, fever, diarrhea, and vomiting….

    The restaurant near Sunchon’s market was immediately ordered to close the following day as city officials launched a joint investigation with the hygiene quarantine office to determine the cause.

    The investigation revealed systemic problems beyond basic food safety violations. Customers reported that the dog meat gave off a strong odor, while authorities discovered that ingredients requiring refrigeration were left at room temperature and eating utensils weren’t properly cleaned due to frequent water outages.

    Restaurant employees told investigators they had to fetch water from a distant well because of inadequate municipal supply. Even more problematic, they were forced to use a refrigerator at another business—a 30-minute walk away—because their own facility lacked sufficient electricity to operate cooling equipment.

    Well, you can see the problem….

  • The early days of the Sandie Peggie case:

    NHS Fife’s bid to resolve the changing room clash between Sandie Peggie and Beth Upton was thrown into disarray when the row exploded into the public eye.

    The health board had urged the Kirkcaldy nurse to stay quiet about her suspension while she was being investigated.

    But emails show how worried NHS Fife staff reacted when it became clear Ms Peggie’s story was about to hit national headlines.

    Ms Peggie did not initially go to the media when she was suspended following her confrontation with Dr Upton on Christmas Eve in 2023.

    But she did contact Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy Alba MP Neale Hanvey, who took an interest in the case.

    Private messages from Ms Peggie to a friend show Mr Hanvey was lobbying the Victoria Hospital nurse to go public with her ordeal.

    “I don’t mind who knows the truth,” Ms Peggie wrote….

    Emails show health board staff were fearful of the impact this would have on Dr Upton.

    But entirely unconcerned about the impact on Sandie Peggie of having to change in front of a man.

    They were particularly worried about a press release from Mr Hanvey referring to the Victoria Hospital doctor as a “trans identifying male”.

    Nicola Robertson, director of nursing, wrote on June 28: “I am concerned for the member of staff to whom this is referring and wondered if anyone might be able to give her the heads up this press release is coming from a parliamentary candidate.

    “The terminology is completely wrong and she should not be referred to as a ‘trans identifying male’.

    “I worry this may cause additional upset.”

    So so desperate to protect Upton from the horror of being misgendered. But of course a ‘trans identifying male’ is exactly what he is.

    Belinda Morgan, the emergency care general manager, flagged Mr Hanvey’s press statement to Kate Searle, Dr Upton’s supervisor.

    “I know you are supporting Beth so not sure if you want to give her the heads up about this and offer any support required,” she wrote.

    Dr Searle replied three days later, after the story had broken.

    “Oh dear,” the consultant wrote.

    “This is so awful.”

    Oh dear indeed.