Trans-identified men aren't used to being thwarted in their fantasy lives as "dolls". For the past few years they've been indulged in virtually every way, from using female toilets to competing in women's sport. Well, times are changing – and the men don't like it.

Jo Bartosch at Spiked:

Robin Moira White has two rock-solid reasons to steer clear of the ladies’ loos. One, he’s male. Two, he’s a barrister, which means he should know better than to treat women’s toilets like a legal grey area (that happens to have nice hand soap). And yet, last week, the trans-activist lawyer breezed right past the unisex loos in Westminster’s Portcullis House and straight into a female-only space.

We should have seen this coming. Last month, White told the BBC’s Woman’s Hour that he would keep using women’s spaces, in defiance of the UK Supreme Court’s ruling in April that men should not be able to access female-only facilities. This applies even if those men have a gender-recognition certificate saying they’re a woman. It is outrageous for anyone, let alone a high-profile barrister, to flagrantly contradict the law like this.

Kate Harris, co-founder of LGB Alliance, and Heather Binning, executive director of the Women’s Rights Network, were at a Women and Equalities Select Committee meeting last week, discussing that very Supreme Court judgment. That was when White, also in attendance, followed them to the ladies’.

‘We suspect he knew exactly what he was doing – and that we, of all women, would challenge him’, Binning told me. ‘Kate and I felt we had no choice but to speak up and tell him – a large man who is about a foot taller than either of us – that he should not be there.’

She found the encounter intimidating, as it was in a small space without cameras or security guards. ‘Silence from other women should not be interpreted by these men as consent [to enter women’s spaces]’, she told me. ‘It is beholden on the rest of the public, the police and employers, to uphold the law and to put practices and policies in place to defend women in society and not to leave it to individual women to take on this role.’

White is far from alone in flouting the rules, of course. As Harris told me:

‘Many male trans activists have expressed their commitment to break the law by continuing to use women’s facilities. This is a form of abuse towards women. The NHS, many MPs, trades unions, universities, schools and a range of public and private organisations have all expressed their willingness to undermine the rule of law by ignoring the Supreme Court ruling. This is unprecedented and should concern all of us who care about liberal democracy. ’

They do it – many of them – because it's an illicit thrill. They enjoy noting the women's discomfort.

White has previously claimed he’s not been challenged when entering women’s spaces because people assume he’s female. I’d suggest the real reason is actually that he looks, and sounds, like an entitled bloke. What has hitherto allowed him to go unchallenged isn’t kindness, it isn’t really even courtesy – it’s fear.

Who wants to be the sales assistant who tells a hulking man in lipstick he’s in the wrong changing room? Or the receptionist who calls a man in a baby doll dress and with a 5 o’clock shadow ‘Sir’? The cost might not only be a job, but one’s front teeth, too….

This is why institutions – from the House of Commons to high-street banks – are pretending biological sex is complicated. It’s precisely because it isn’t complicated – and they don’t want to offend entitled, bullying men.

For all my strident views, if I found myself alone with a man like White in the ladies’, I would be hesitant to speak up. Not out of kindness – and not because I’m a coward. But because it’s a risk I simply can’t afford to take.

The threat of violence is always there – as women know only too well.

Added:

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Posted in

Leave a comment